The Best of Both Worlds: Combine Hydraulic and Servo Technology and Save Up To 80% of Energy Costs

Michael Stiegler, Baumüller Nürnberg GmbH

Read min.

One prefix changes everything. Servo- with hydraulic renders a precision-regulated drive. But what does servo-hydraulics actually do? What challenges go along with making the change? This is what we explain in this post.

In which cases does a change from unregulated hydraulic system with standard motor to regulated servo-hydraulics make sense

Robust and powerful

Hydraulic systems are used in industrial applications

Classic hydraulic applications have many advantages: The hydraulics ensure high force and power density and low inertias, with drive elements that are robust and relatively cost-efficient. But there are other possibilities – presses and injection molding machines are just two of many examples of applications where it makes sense to consider alternatives.

Hydraulic systems compared

In the past, the following solutions have often been used in hydraulic applications to control pressure and volumetric flow:

Cost-efficient and robust: Asynchronous standard motor connected to the power supply with constant pump

Asynchronous standard motor connected to the power supply with constant pump

In systems with valve-controlled drives with standard motors and constant pumps, the electro motor permanently rotates with the power frequency. With the constant pump, there is a constant pumping of the volumetric flow. Here proportional valves are used for pressure and volume control. 

The acquisition costs for the system as a whole with uncontrolled asynchronous motor are usually lower overall than with other solutions, but the service life costs are comparatively high due to the high energy consumption.

Advantage: Low acquisition costs through the use of standard motors.

Disadvantages:

  • High noise emissions through continuous operation of the standard motor
  • High costs for the valve technology
  • High energy consumption through continuous operation at constant speed

System with standard motor connected to the power system and electro-hydraulic variable adjustment pump

Standard motor connected to the power supply with electro-hydraulic variable adjustment pump

Electro-hydraulic variable adjustment pumps are also usually powered by asynchronous motors. In these applications, the motor rotates permanently at constant speed, and pressure and volumetric pressure are controlled via axial piston pump.

Using variable adjustment pumps improves the energy balance of the system. But it still results in considerable losses and disadvantages such as the high noise load.

Advantage: Higher energy efficiency than with a combination of asynchronous motor and constant pump, as power loss is lower with the variable adjustment pump.

Disadvantages:

  • Variable adjustment pumps are more expensive than constant pumps
  • High noise emissions through continuous operation of the standard motor
  • Asynchronous motor still consumes unused energy in partial load range

The problem: Fluctuating needs for hydraulic output

In hydraulic applications, energy consumption depends critically on system pressure and volumetric flow, which supply the required hydraulic output.

The machine cycle in the example in the figure shows the pressure required for each partial cycle in [Bar], the oil quantity pumped in [L/min] as well as the resulting hydraulic output in [kW].

The requirements of the partial cycles vary considerably for each process step. Closing the press, for example, requires a very high hydraulic output – the output results from the high pressure briefly required and the high pumping quantity.

The next step requires significantly less hydraulic output because although the pressure is greater than in the first sub-step, the required oil quantity is significantly lower.

Pressure, pumped quantity of oil and motor output in the individual cycle phases – large differences in the required hydraulic output

Save energy with servo-hydraulic drive systems

The solution: High power density combines with high energy efficiency

Servo-hydraulic machines combine the advantages of hydraulic power transfer with the advantages of servo-drive technology: High output densities, low inertias and cost-effective and robust drive elements meet dynamic and precise speed control. Energy consumption is thus reduced significantly. Here the low heat and noise development, the high effectiveness and above-average dynamics and precision are typical advantages of servo technology.

Servo motor with constant pump

The drive package of servo-hydraulic systems consists of a constant pump, a servo motor and a converter with integrated "servo-hydraulics" technology package. The Baumüller servo motor powers the pump. The servo-electric pump propulsion is controlled separately by a servo-controller.

In each cycle step, the quantity and pressure control of the pump is precisely adapted to the particular needs by adjusting the motor speed. The drive stops for process-specific cycle pauses of the hydraulic consumers, resulting in no energy consumption. In phases of pressure control, the motor turns at just the required speed and thus consumes just as much energy as is necessary to maintain pressure control.

Because the drive only generates output when the servo pump is used, when it is actually used the machine consumes far less energy. Up to 50 percent savings is possible compared to classic solutions, and with longer cycles without force requirements up to 80 percent. The result is significantly reduced service life costs, and in many cases the initially higher cost pays for itself within a year.

An additional aspect is the significantly reduced noise load. Conventional hydraulic systems give off constant noise because of the permanently running main drive, even when no hydraulic energy is needed.

Smaller machine footprint

Because the control of pressure and volumetric flow is covered directly in the drive control cycle at fast cycle times of 125 microseconds, very dynamic and precise control is possible. These excellent control properties result in high repeat precision, which allows better product and process quality. Each hydraulic axis can be stored with its own control parameter sets in the controller, tailored to the particular consumer.

Advantages:

  • Significantly lower energy consumption through control of the pump drive
  • Lower noise emissions
  • Higher process and product quality
  • Compact drive system and smaller machine footprint

Disadvantages:       -   Higher initial costs

Servo-hydraulics pays off with:
  • Processes with strong fluctuations in power requirements
  • Processes with long pause cycles
  • Noise load too high
Does this concept suit your application?

When it is worth switching to servohydraulics - all information in our webcast (15 minutes)!

Example applications

Example: Injection molding machine
Example of a cycle of an injection molding machine

The principle of servo-hydraulics can be very well illustrated in the example of the cycle of an injection molding machine. The manufacturing of plastic cups or bottle stoppers consists of six steps: plasticizing, dosing, injecting, molding, cooling and demolding. These production steps are highly differentiated, meaning that within one process step the injection molding machine has widely fluctuating output requirements. Closing and injection sequences require large quantities of hydraulic oil and a high volumetric flow. Cooling times, on the other hand, require no or just minimal output.

The difference in energy consumption between the three systems presented is clearly visible in the graphic. The high energy efficiency of the servo-hydraulic solution arises from a needs-specific pump output. When the machine is at rest, e.g. during cooling, then the motors will also be at rest and will consume no energy.

Example: Press
Example of a cycle of a press

An additional example is presses. The cycle in the figure is divided into three partial cycles: Press forward (compression of material), hold time, press back and removal time. The comparison of energy consumption between the three different systems shows that the servo-hydraulic solution in the individual partial cycles has a significantly lower power input and thus has a significantly lower energy consumption overall. Unlike conventional hydraulic systems, only the energy that is actually needed is used, while in the classic systems the losses are higher due to the constant revolution of the standard motor in rest phases, such as when stopped (see figure).

Change to servo-hydraulics: Simpler than you think

The change from the classic hydraulic systems to servo-hydraulic systems should be managed in collaboration with an experienced application team. To design the drive system, the cycle of the machine as well as the pressure and volumetric flow profile of the machine over time is required. With this information, the servo-hydraulic system can be designed with its components using calculation software from the manufacturer.

Is servo-hydraulics right for you?

The integration of the new solution with the machine layout likewise can usually also be carried out without any major challenges. Activation through the machine controller can be analog or via modern bus systems. The old system of asynchronous and control pump or asynchronous machine and constant pump can in many cases be replaced 1:1 with servo-hydraulics.

Other application examples for servo-hydraulics

Injection molding machines and presses are not the only applications for servo-motor pumps. Anywhere that phases with high output requirements alternate with pause times in the machine cycle, the use of a servo-hydraulic system can make sense, such as in stamping and bending machines.

The advantages of hydraulic power transfer and electric power setting using servo technology combined, as an alternative to hydraulic pressure and volumetric flow control, yields an energy-efficient and cost-effective solution in the form of a dynamically controllable servo pump.

Do you have further questions?

Michael Stiegler
Application

Our responsible expert will be happy to assist you.

Invalid Input
Please fill in first name
Please fill in last name
Invalid Input
Please fill in the company name
Please provide a street and number
Please fill in zip code
Invalid Input
Please select a country
Invalid Input
Private email domains are excluded
Invalid Input

You can find information on data protection in our privacy policy declaration.

Spamprotection failed.
The fields marked with an asterisk (*) are mandatory.